The legendary MS Dhoni, at 43, continues to defy age as the oldest captain in IPL history, leading Chennai Super Kings (CSK) for an unprecedented 18 seasons. However, after CSK’s disappointing 2025 campaign that saw them finish at the bottom of the table, questions are being raised about whether the iconic wicketkeeper-batsman has extended his stay beyond its ideal conclusion.
Former India spinner Murali Kartik recently sparked debate by suggesting that even beloved athletes must recognize when it’s time to exit gracefully. “You don’t want the ones who love you to say, ‘You have overstayed your welcome’,” Kartik remarked during a Cricbuzz discussion, drawing parallels to Virat Kohli’s recent Test retirement at 36 despite being in peak fitness.
The captaincy conundrum adds another layer to the debate. Dhoni was forced to reclaim leadership duties this season after Ruturaj Gaikwad’s injury, leaving fans wondering about CSK’s future direction. Kartik believes the franchise must allow Gaikwad to establish his own leadership identity rather than constantly comparing him to Dhoni’s legendary tenure.
As speculation mounts about Dhoni’s next move, the cricket world remains divided. Some argue his experience is invaluable, while others believe CSK’s rebuilding phase requires fresh leadership. With Dhoni famously keeping his cards close to his chest, only time will tell if the Thala magic continues or if this marks the end of an era for Chennai Super Kings.
By
